Awe, Curiosity and False Idols

Finding meaning inside the murmurations we cannot fully see.

More than one flock

A murmuration is easier to admire from the ground than from somewhere in the middle. From below, we see the sweeping shape. Imagine being one of the birds, responding to its neighbours while helping to create something it cannot survey from our position.

In Life Inside the Murmuration, I explored this predicament. But there is an important addition: we belong to multiple murmurations. Families, workplaces, cultures, economies and ecosystems overlap, yet they do not necessarily move together. Keeping up at work can mean neglecting home.

How might we find meaning in belonging to these larger patterns without pretending to fully understand them?

Awe without a final answer

Awe is the wonder we feel when something’s beauty, scale or complexity makes us pause and take notice. A sunset can do it. So can contemplating humanity’s progress: the knowledge, cities and technologies that have grown from countless lives and generations.

For Biotheism, we are particularly interested in the awe of recognising the complex patterns around us. We glimpse what people and other living things produce together, far beyond what any individual could achieve. We realise that we belong to these patterns too.

There is something bigger at play than our immediate experience can account for. We can be impressed by it, moved by it, even feel a sense of belonging within it, without knowing what the whole amounts to.

The experience is real. It does not come with an explanation attached.

Give wonder something to do

Awe is being struck by what we see, even when we cannot explain it. Curiosity is the pursuit of understanding.

That search can occupy a lifetime. We do not have to complete it for it to be worthwhile.

Biotheism’s commitments to ignorance and to evidence belong together. An incomplete view is not a useless one. We can distinguish better explanations from worse ones without possessing a final account of everything.

Learning how something works need not ruin our wonder. It may even enlarge it. But enquiry must also be allowed to spoil an attractive story, including one we have begun to call spiritual.

False idols

Religions offer an explanation for the murmuration we cannot see. They tell us what lies behind it, why we are here, how we should behave, and often what happens when we die. It is a highly attractive offer.

But offering a complete explanation is not the same as having one. I don’t believe religions possess the knowledge they claim. Their accounts are human explanations, not demonstrated views from outside the flock.

Emergent ignorance, the Biogenic idea that participation can leave us blind to larger patterns, gives us reason to distrust such certainty. A religious institution is part of the murmuration too.

That does not render every religious insight worthless. The false idol is the explanation that has been placed beyond question. Biotheism is no exception. Calling our account biological does not grant us privileged access either. I am still one of the birds.

A few ways to practise

The practices can be modest. There is no need to adopt all of them.

Locate yourself. Begin the day by asking: “Where am I in the web of life today?” Notice the several systems you participate in. Which occupy your attention? Which have you forgotten? Consider where their demands conflict. Belonging does not oblige you to serve every pattern equally, nor to mistake participation for obedience.

Return to something ordinary. Walk the same path regularly, tend a plant, or watch compost change. Look for growth, organisation, and correction, the processes Biogenics asks us to notice. What is being produced? How are the parts working together? What is adjusting or recovering? There is no requirement to feel awestruck. Give the familiar a little more attention than usual.

Give one question a longer life. Record something puzzling, then investigate it. Read outside your field, seek contrary evidence, and ask someone whose position offers a different view. Return to the question. An unexpected coincidence can start an investigation without becoming a message from the universe. Do this with others occasionally. Bring an example of emergence into a shared conversation, and see what survives someone else’s questions.

Notice your effects. At the end of the day, ask: “Did I strengthen or weaken my connections today?” Think about an act of listening, cooperation, care or repair. What happened that you did not anticipate? This is not a score for spiritual performance. It is a chance to learn about the patterns you help create.

An honest participant

Meaning need not wait until we know what everything is ultimately for. It can grow through relationships, enquiry and care. The aim is to become a more honest participant, not the bird with the definitive explanation.

At the next shared meal, there is no need to explain the universe to everyone. You might begin by listening to someone whose version you do not yet understand.

 

Next
Next

Is Biotheism a Religion?